By Josh Donner

22nd April 2025

Pensions – the payroll onboarding problem hiding in plain sight

It’s been more than a decade since automatic enrolment came into effect, yet workplace pensions remain one of the biggest stumbling blocks we encounter when onboarding new payroll clients

You might expect that, after 10+ years, most employers would have pension compliance locked down. But that’s far from the reality. Even well-run businesses, with reputable payroll providers and diligent internal teams, often find themselves caught out by complexities that have crept in over time.

At Ascend Payroll, we’ve learned that pensions are the area most likely to trip up an otherwise clean payroll transition.

And the cost of getting it wrong can be significant, both financially and reputationally.

Why is this still a problem?

Workplace pensions are not just a ‘set and forget’ arrangement. Schemes evolve, and so does legislation. Auto-enrolment duties shift with workforce changes and admin shortcuts taken years ago can snowball into compliance risks today.

In many cases, clients are unaware of hidden issues until we start digging as part of our onboarding process..

What we’re seeing;

  • Inaccurate postponement practices
  • Outdated pension scheme settings
  • Incorrect application of thresholds and categories
  • Contribution miscalculations due to salary sacrifice changes
  • Missed re-enrolment dates and incomplete communications

How we fix it

As part of our onboarding process, our pensions specialists carry out a detailed review of every scheme we take on.

We look under the hood to assess;

  • Scheme administration practices
  • Record-keeping accuracy
  • Employer duties compliance
  • Provider configuration and data mapping

Where needed, we’ll work with providers and clients to resolve gaps, clean up legacy issues, and ensure everything is aligned with current legislation and best practice.

Because payroll isn’t just about paying people – it’s about protecting your people, brand, and business.

If pensions are hiding issues in your payroll setup, they will eventually come to light – either through audit, error, or enforcement.
When we take on new clients, we will uncover all these problems so we can be sure the pension data is clean and accurate and then keep on top of any changes that may cause ongoing problems.

If you, or your payroll provider, has not reviewed your pension payroll set up, you could be in for a shock if you need to move your payroll.

Pension administration is a key part of the Ascend Payroll service, our team is fully up to date with the latest in pension legislation.

As part of our managed payroll service, we can also provide pension management and auto-enrolment compliance;

  • Assessing who in your workforce is eligible for auto-enrolment each pay period
  • Auto enrolling eligible employees
  • Dealing with opt-in and opt-outs
  • Processing any cessation in contributions
  • Reporting on scheduled pension contributions
  • Filing to the pension provider
  • Arranging payment of contributions to pension provider (if a required service).

Interested in our pension payroll services? Let’s arrange a chat to see how we can transform your payroll services. Want to learn more about Ascend Payroll? Read our customer promise to see how were protecting our customers.

Frequently asked questions related to this blog

Why are workplace pensions still causing problems more than a decade after auto-enrolment?

Workplace pensions are not a “set and forget” arrangement. Schemes evolve, legislation changes, and auto-enrolment duties shift with workforce changes. Admin shortcuts taken years ago can snowball into compliance risks today. Even well-run businesses with reputable payroll providers and diligent internal teams often find themselves caught out by complexities that have crept in over time. Pensions remain the area most likely to trip up an otherwise clean payroll transition, and the cost of getting it wrong can be significant, both financially and reputationally.

What common pension compliance issues do employers overlook?

In many cases, clients are unaware of hidden issues until a thorough review begins. Common problems include inaccurate postponement practices, outdated pension scheme settings, incorrect application of thresholds and categories, contribution miscalculations due to salary sacrifice changes, and missed re-enrolment dates with incomplete communications. If pensions are hiding issues in your payroll setup, they will eventually come to light through audit, error, or enforcement. If you or your payroll provider has not reviewed your pension payroll setup, you could be in for a shock if you need to move your payroll.

What should a proper pension payroll review cover?

A detailed review should assess scheme administration practices, record-keeping accuracy, employer duties compliance, and provider configuration and data mapping. Where needed, work with providers and clients to resolve gaps, clean up legacy issues, and ensure everything is aligned with current legislation and best practice. Payroll is not just about paying people. It is about protecting your people, brand, and business.

What pension management services can a payroll provider offer?

As part of a managed payroll service, pension management and auto-enrolment compliance can include assessing who in the workforce is eligible for auto-enrolment each pay period, auto-enrolling eligible employees, dealing with opt-ins and opt-outs, processing any cessation in contributions, reporting on scheduled pension contributions, filing to the pension provider, and arranging payment of contributions to the pension provider if required.

How can employers avoid pension problems during a payroll transition?

Get pensions reviewed before you need to move payroll, not during the move itself. Uncover problems early so pension data is clean and accurate, then keep on top of any changes that may cause ongoing issues. Make sure whoever handles your payroll is fully up to date with the latest pension legislation and understands that auto-enrolment duties are ongoing, not a one-time setup task. A proactive review now can save significant financial and reputational damage later.

Love this post? why not share it...

Let’s have a chat about how we can transform your payroll

"Ready to ascend" - Badge